Business Partnership Advisor

Together, we can fix your business and partnership problems

Chris Reich, Business Mediator

You Can Backdate Agreements in Business Legally

Chris, my business partner and I are breaking up the partnership. I want out because we have issues. I don't want to be responsible for this year's bills. Can we backdate a deal to get me out legally?

YES, It Is Legal to Backdate a Business Buyout or Other Restructure

Many people are trying to work out new arrangements with their business partner but find themselves in bad place on the calendar. Despite both parties agreeing to a change, it could take months to worth out the terms. Don't worry. Some agreements can be legally backdated for years.

The easy answer is "Yes", you can backdate. There are things to be careful of when backdating. Let's take a look how to do it right.

The First Question: Why Are We Backdating the Deal?

Of course, the answer is always the same. You don't want to carry all the accounting hassles into another year. One partner doesn't plan to take income in the current year and doesn't want the current year's liabilities. And, there is that legal case pending against the business and you'd like to avoid that too, right? Whoa. Just a minute.

Are you trying to escape the consequences of an event that's already happened? If the partners flip a coin and decide who will be free of a lawsuit already filed against the business, it's not going to be a legal backdate.

You want to be careful about why you are backdating. Let's look at the two classifications of backdating; one is acceptable and the other is not.

It is legal to backdate a business deal

Don't let the date prevent you from working out a deal between partners. We can legally backdate and achieve everyone's goals. Chris Reich, Business Mediator

The Backdating Test

In order to determine if it's okay to backdate we must determine if we are memorializing a deal or committing fraud. Easy, right? Actually it is pretty easy. Let's look at some examples.

Partnership Buyout #1

The are three partners in a business. One partner decides that she no longer want to be a partner and is willing to sell her interest in the business to the other partners. She makes her intention known on December 1, 2019. The other partners begin negotiations with her on the price and terms of a buyout. They offer $20,000 for her interest in the business. She insists that her share is worth $300,000. Despite numerous meetings, by June of 2020, the parties are still trying to find an acceptable compromise.

In December of 2020, a deal is reached for $175,000 in cash but the remaining partners want the deal dated effective December 31, 2019. Can we do that?

The answer is yes. We are simply memorializing (creating a record) of a deal that was made in principle in a previous time. If the partner worked in 2020, we have to consider how to report those earnings. If the sale happened in the prior year, payments to the departing partner will be treated (and taxed) as wages. We might reconsider the sale date. Regardless, it's perfectly legal to backdate under these circumstances. Why? We are memorializing a deal that was begun in an earlier time.

Partnership Buyout #2

A business has 2 partners. An employee is injured on the job and the business is in deep trouble. The partners have a great idea that can save the business. One partner buys out the other partner and hands over all the cash reserves the business has. They agree to backdate the sale to well before the accident. The departing partner also takes the bulk of the inventory and key equipment as part of his buyout. Legal? No.

In this case, the backdating is clearly designed to escape the consequences of the accident. There was no prior discussion about a buyout. And, even if there was, this deal was clearly designed as a way to fraud the employee from a potential settlement.

Memorializing or Fraud? How to Decide

This is a pretty easy question most of the time. Of course, there are always cases that fall in the gray area, but if the deal doesn't hurt anyone, and if you have some basis for a backdate, you won't have a problem.

Don't let the calendar keep you from getting out of a bad situation. You can start the discussions now and backdate to the prior year for the sake of keeping your books simple as long as income is properly accounted.

How Far Back Can You Go?

I'm not sure there is a legal limit so long as it's clear that the deal memorializes a transaction and is not designed to fraud anyone (including the government). I have participated in deals that were backdated by years without issues. That's rather unusual but there are times when backdating makes great sense.

 

Did You Like This Post? Would You Please Rate It?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 4.6 / 5. Vote count: 35

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

"Don't let the calendar keep you from getting out of a bad situation. You can start the discussions now and backdate to the prior year for the sake of keeping your books simple."

Are You Ready to End the Stress of Your Partnership Problems? Contact Me Now for a 100% Confidential Consultation.

Prefer a direct approach?

Email: Chris@TeachU.com

Phone: (530) 467-5690

50/50 Business Partner Deadlock: How Mediation Breaks the Stalemate Without Destroying the Company

A 50/50 business partner deadlock is a decision failure, not automatically the end of the company. Mediation helps equal owners identify exactly what is blocked, separate business facts from accumulated grievances, and negotiate a workable path – renewed decision rules, a division of authority, a buyout, or an orderly separation. The mediator does not impose the result; the owners retain control of the outcome.

When the Problem Partner Doesn’t Propose Solutions

Sadly, the ugly reality is that if your partner complains but doesn’t offer solutions, he’s no longer a partner. A wise lawyer once taught me this important lesson when he was drawn into a nasty partnership dispute that I was working on. One of the partners was always complaining that the other was never bringing ideas to the table. The lawyer, after listening to the whining for 15 minutes said, “Tom, you need to learn to deal with the partner you have, not the one you wish you had.”

List of All Business Partnership Mediation Articles

This Page is a searchable index of all posts pertaining to Business Partnership Mediations. This page is an excellent resource for articles about partnership mediation. Find all categories including Partnership Disputes, Family Business Mediation, and Partnership Agreement.

How a Mediator Can Help Your Family Business

As Moderator to many family businesses, I have helped with succession planning, compensation planning, and resolving of key questions around the operation of the enterprise. It can be difficult for an adult offspring to talk with Dad about a raise.

What Makes a Contract Legal and Binding?

As you see, a contract can be legal yet not binding. And, the most important take away is that a promise, even if written up and signed, is not binding. If an agreement is not binding, it isn’t enforceable. I assume you want your agreements between you and your partner(s) to be legal, binding, and enforceable. Let’s look at the pieces that must be included to make a valid, binding contract.

The Best Tool for Successful Negotiation

Before I give you the secret to easier and successful negotiation, let me explain a few things that don’t work. In fact, these will work against you. From years of watching people negotiate buying or selling, trying to change processes, or reaching general agreement, I have seen what works and what doesn’t when partners are negotiating with each other.

Chris Reich, Business Partnership Mediator can help you fix the communication issues with your partner.

Problems in the Partnership? Fix the Communication

I’ve found a common problem with communication when I’m conducting mediation meetings. People always think they know what the other party is thinking. They’ll say things like, “I know Bill won’t like this, but I think…” Opening your thoughts with that sort of lead in is going to put ‘Bill’ on edge before you even make your point. Never start by negatively setting the stage. So then, how should you start a conversation about a hard subject? In this post I’ll give you the 7 steps to conduct less tense and more fruitful meetings with your business partner.

This is the most important clause in your operating agreement: How to treat the voluntary exit of a partner?

The Most Important Clause in Your Operating Agreement

To be fair, many Operating Agreements have at least minimal language regarding a Partner’s voluntary exit from the Partnership. But, most of the time, those clauses are so vague they make the situation worse.

Business partners having a discussion across a desk. Scene feels tense

Can You Be You with Your Business Partner?

Partnerships are much like romantic relationships. When it’s all new and exciting, we can easily become infatuated to the point of overlooking differences. After all, don’t the differences make the partnership stronger? Sometimes. Most often differences magnify with time and become triggers to arguments. As time goes by, the differences you ignored become important. What do you do when the differences break the partnership?

Image of chef looking angry. Chris is expressing the desire he has sometimes to want to yell at disputing parties to get their act together and avoid court.

I Want to go Gordon Ramsay Sometimes!

Sometimes, in Partnership Mediations, people will dig into very irrational positions. And sometimes, when there is tension in a partnership, as a professional mediator, I can see an easy solution. When disputants won’t do simple things to protect their business, it makes me want to scream!

Image shows folded hands over a contract being negotiated.

5 Tips for Successful Buyout Negotiations

My business partner and I can no longer work together. We’ve tried to talk about a buyout—I want to buy him out—but it always leads to an argument. Do you have any suggestions for conducting buyout talks that don’t turn into an argument? Read these tips to conduct Buyout negotiations without tension.

Father and Son as image for Family Business Succession Planning.

Make a Succession Plan for the Family Business

Family Business Succession Planning: Make a definite plan. How will they support the parents and when can they take charge. That’s what they want.

Image of two people negotiating a partnership buyout with the text "Buyout Negotiation Tips"

10 Tips to Conduct a Successful Partnership Buyout

Before I offer you my tips on conducting the buyout negotiations with your partner, let me offer a big piece of advice. Use a Mediator. I say that because there is a LOT of emotion around buyouts. It is an extremely personal and emotional process. People always underestimate just how emotional separating from a business is.

The image shows an angry man pointing a finger at these words, "Be careful when dealing with a high-conflict business partner. Here are some key tips to help keep the drama down."

6 Steps to Deal With a High Conflict (Bully) Business Partner

The High Conflict Business Partner AKA the Bully is the most difficult type of person to deal with. Here are 6 Tips to help you deal with the Bully Partner.

5 Red Flags That Say Your Business Partnership is in Trouble

Business partnerships can be a fantastic way to pool resources and knowledge in order to create a successful enterprise. However, even the most well-intentioned partnerships can break down if certain warning signs are ignored. In this post, I will point out the 5 red flags that should never be ignored when you see them in your business partnership and provide you with guidance on how to deal with them.

Eventually a partner is going to want to leave the business. Plan ahead advises Chris Reich of TeachU.

Plan for the Day a Partner Wants to Leave the Business

If you have read my other posts, you know I strongly encourage people who form Partnerships to create a Partnership Agreement. The document must specify how a Partner can leave the Partnership voluntarily while ensuring that the business is protected from two potential disasters: firstly, by avoiding terms that could bankrupt the business, and secondly, by preventing the admission of unplanned Partners.

This article is about why people in mediation should be civil to each other.

7 Reasons to Be Extra Nice in a Partnership Mediation

When partners seek mediation to resolve conflicts or disputes, it is important that they approach the process with a civil and respectful attitude. Partnership mediation is a non-adversarial way of resolving disputes, and it requires cooperation and collaboration from both parties.

Image about succession planning showing father and son in business.

Succession Planning in Family Business

Let’s look at how to plan for the next generation of your family to run your business. It’s never too early to make a succession plan and the earlier you start, the more options you have.

You can get out of a business partnership if you planned ahead with a solid Partnership Agreement.

How to Escape Your Business Partnership

How do I get out of my partnership? And, it’s the biggest reason I am always ranting about having a Partnership Agreement. Without a Partnership Agreement, your options are very limited. You accept anything your partner is willing to give you, or you can dissolve the business.

Take the proper steps to protect the money you invest to start your new business partnership.

Don’t Risk the Money You Put Into Your Partnership

Somebody puts up money with someone who agrees to contribute labor as their contribution to an equal Partnership. Once things are set up, and a lot of money is spent, the other Partner fails to perform, and the troubles begin. I get 2-3 calls like this every week.